TNC’s New City, New Blood Reading Series: A Strange Union

Theater for the New City

Executive Director, Crystal Field

Presents

TNC’s New City, New Blood Reading Series:

A Strange Union

Written and  Directed  by Tyler Plosia

Thursday, August 28, 2025 at 6:30 PM

FREE

$5 Suggested Donation

To make a reservation name and # of tickets to tncdreamup@gmail.com

THEATER FOR THE NEW CITY
155 First Avenue (between 9th & 10th Street)
New York, NY 10003
Directions

A Strange Union is set on an NJ transit train and involves the meeting of three strangers. Two of them find an unusual, performative connection, pretending to be husband and wife—and the third is a nuisance.

CAST
Jalila is being played by Samia Omari.
Colin is being played by Shamar James.
Catcaller is being played by Joseph Sweadner.

Playwright and Director Bio: Tyler Plosia is a writer and educator who lives in Brooklyn, New York. He holds an MFA in Playwriting from Queens College, and teaches writing at Seton Hall University and Kean University. His plays have been produced as a part of the Thespis Theater Festival, the Last Frontier Theatre Conference and Rooted Theater Company’s Fall Symposium.

Dream Up Festival 2025

THEATER FOR THE NEW CITY
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, CRYSTAL FIELD
PRESENTS

DREAM UP FESTIVAL 2025

THEATER FOR THE NEW CITY SETS ITS 13th DREAM UP FESTIVAL

All events at THEATER FOR THE NEW CITY
155 First Avenue (between 9th and 10th Street)
New York, NY 10003
Directions

August 24 to September 14, 2025

For Dream Up Festival tickets, go to: https://WWW.DREAMUPFESTIVAL.ORG/SHOWS – $15-$20
For additional info, call the TNC box office at 212-254-1109.

In 2010, the inaugural Dream Up Festival offered 25 shows consisting of 23 World Premieres and 2 American Premieres. The festival had reviewers from NY Times, NY Press, Show business Weekly, the Advocate, NYTheatre.com and others.

NEW YORK — From August 24 to September 14, 2025Theater for the New City (TNC), under the direction of Crystal Field, will resume its 13th  Dream Up Festival, a feast of adventurous theater.  The annual event is an ultimate new works festival, dedicated to the joy of discovering new authors and edgy, innovative performances.

The Festival is helmed by the theater’s Literary Manager, Michael Scott-Price.  This year it offers 22 plays. Audiences will savor the excitement, awe, passion, challenge and intrigue of new plays from around the country.

Theater for the New City has consistently been the most inexpensive theater of its caliber and it continues its commitment to affordable tickets with this festival. Dream Up Festival tickets are $15-$20 for all participating productions.

The festival does not seek out traditional scripts that are presented in a traditional way. It selects works that push new ideas to the forefront, challenge audience expectations and make us question our understanding of how art illuminates the world around us.

Theater for the New City (TNC) maintains a distinctive commitment to high artistic values and community service. In an effort to make theater accessible to all, TNC presents an assortment of distinct, exceptional events each year, including the Lower East Side Festival of the Arts, which celebrates the artistic and cultural diversity of TNC’s Lower East Side community; an annual Village Halloween Ball and an annual summer Street Theater tour that presents a free, live, original musical in thirteen neighborhoods in all five boroughs. Most of these are free of charge to the public.

Go to https://www.dreamupfestival.org/shows.html for more information and full schedule

LIST OF PRODUCTIONS

Breaking the Trust
– NY Premiere – Playwright: Bill Rogers, Director: Gerald vanHeerden

Con*Cussed
– World Premiere – Writer: Elizabeth Alice Murray, Director: Roger Cacchiotti

Dismantling Prospero
– Workshop – Playwright: Tom Rowan, Director: Kevin Ray, Producer: Marty Goldin

Dune: The Dunesical
– World Premiere – Written and Directed by Blake Du Bois and TJ Canlon

First Liar on the Moon
– World Premiere – Written and Directed by Fletcher Michael

Fury
– Workshop – Written by Paul Kouri

Gin & Milk
– World Premiere – Written and Directed by: Antony Raymond

Green Herrings in a Yellow Room: A Counter Production of The Yellow Wallpaper
– World Premiere – Written, directed, and designed by Sloan Aulgur

In Between Sessions
– World Premiere – Written by Amy Coleman, Directed by Roger Cacchiotti

In Search of “True Love”
– Written by Ayaka Yamamoto

Kind Stranger:…a memory play
– World Premiere – Adapted for Stage by: Steven Simone-Friedlan

Little Jewel: In the Plagues and Throes of Love
– World Premiere – Writer and Director: Bob Shuman

One in Twenty-Five
– World Premiere – Writer and Director: Thomas M Copeland

Sartre and Simone: A Comedy of Redemptive Love
– World Premiere – Written and directed by: William Cane

That Lost Orange Sauce
– World Premiere – Writer: Evan Davis, Director: Elena Menendez Sanchez

The Boys From Kingsbridge
– World Premiere – Written by: Steven Sarao

The Shadows of Love and Light
– World Premiere – Playwright: Larry Americ Allen, Director: Jill Giedt

The Story of Sal B and Barbranne: A mob fantasia
– World Premiere – Written and Directed by Stephan Morrow

To Feed the Roses
Written by Amy Losi, Directed by Laurie Rae Waugh

Twist of Faith
Written by: Michael Gurin
Based on an original story by: Matt Okin & Michael Gurin

Undesirable Secrets
– NY Premiere – Written and performed by: Rodolfo Avarado

TNC Street Theater Summer Tour – HOME SWEET HOME or A LIFE IN NEW YORK (2025)

Executive Director, Crystal Field

Presents:

TNC Street Theater Summer Tour – HOME SWEET HOME or A LIFE IN NEW YORK

August 2 – September 14, 2025
Free! In The Streets!
Saturdays and Sundays @ 2 PM; Friday Performance in Coney Island @ 5:00 PM (full schedule below)

Writer and Director – Crystal Field
Composer – Peter Dizozza

8/2 • 2pm • Manhattan • TNC at E. 10th St. & First Ave.
8/3 • 2pm • Bronx • St. Mary’s Park at 147th St. & St. Ann’s Ave.
8/9 • 2pm • Staten Island • Tappen Park btw. Canal & Water Streets
8/10 • 2pm • Manhattan • Central Park Bandshell, 72nd Street Crosswalk
8/15 • 5pm • Brooklyn • Coney Island Boardwalk at W. 10st St.
8/16 • 2pm • Manhattan • St. Marks Church at E. 10th St. & Second Ave.
8/17 • 2pm • Manhattan • Jackie Robinson Park at W. 147th St. & Bradhurst Ave.
8/23 • 2pm • Manhattan • Washington Square Park
8/24 • 2pm • Queens • Travers Park at 34th Ave. btw. 77th & 78th Streets
9/6 • 2pm • Brooklyn • Sunset Park at 6th Ave. & 44th St.
9/7 • 2pm • Brooklyn • Fort Greene Park, Myrtle Avenue & St. Edwards Street
9/13 • 2pm • Manhattan • Sol Bloom Playground, W 91st Street btw. Columbus Ave & Central Park West
9/14 • 2pm • Manhattan • Tompkins Square Park at E. 7th St. & Ave. A

NEW YORK – Theater for the New City’s award-winning Street Theater Company will open its 2025 annual tour Saturday, August 2 with “Home Sweet Home, or A Life In New York,” a rip-roaring original musical which tells a story of a young orphan, born in America but longing to understand his roots, as deportations shake the lives of his immigrant friends. Book, lyrics and direction are by Crystal Field, Artistic Director of Theater for the New City (TNC). The musical score is composed and arranged by Peter Dizozza. Free performances will tour parks, playgrounds and closed-off streets throughout the five boroughs through September 14.

TNC’s Street Theater has impacted generations of audiences, encouraging the younger generation to make a difference in their own neighborhoods. Productions have celebrated the diversity of our heritage, the strength of our citizens, and the optimistic hope for a successful road to their future.  This year’s play is a story of a young man, an orphan seeking his family roots, at a time when many of his friends are being deported. He was born in America but he knows in his heart that he has a kinship to his fellow young New Yorkers who are suffering greatly and whose sense of security is greatly threatened. He dreams of his desire to become a teacher. In his dream, the Statue of Liberty rises up and embraces him. She reaches out to call out to his friends who hang onto her skirt as the waters of the ocean pull them away.

The owner of the local bodega, where the young man works, is an emigre from Guyana who had proudly obtained his citizenship 20 years ago. Every Sunday morning he plays chess with his friend, the local Firefighter from the Firehouse next door. Together, the two men take the Young Man under their wing and help him find his roots. They sing of fighting fires throughout history (Slavery! Fascism! Atomic War!). Now our beloved Nation suffers immigrant deportation. They summon Lady Liberty and plead for her aid. Lady Liberty appears surrounded by native New Yorkers who support her and guide her new-found children to safety. The musical score includes bold songs like “Pilgrims to the Present” and “We Fight Fire,” culminating in “Together at Last,” a hopeful finale that celebrates unity, diversity, and the dream of a just future.

The production will be staged with an elaborate assemblage of trap doors, giant puppets, smoke machines, masks, original choreography and a huge (9′ x 12′) running screen or “cranky” providing continuous moving scenery behind the actors. The company of 22 actors, ten crew members, two stage managers, three assistant directors and five live musicians (led by the composer at the keyboard) will share the challenge of performing outside and holding a large, non-captive audience. The music will vary in style from Bossa Nova to Hip Hop to Musical Comedy to classical Cantata. The play is a bouncy joyride through the undulations of the body politic, with astute commentary couched in satire, song and slapstick.

TNC’s free Street Theater productions are delightfully suited for family audiences, since complex social issues are often presented through children’s allegories, with children and neighborhood people as the heroes.

Michael David Gordon heads the cast of 22 as the Bodega Owner.  The five-piece band is led by composer Peter Dizozza.

Theater for the New City has mounted a new musical for a five borough tour each year since 1976. In 2020, in response to the Covid-19 lockdown, TNC’s Street Theater production, “Liberty or Just Us: a City Park Story,” was an oratorio that live streamed for an eight week, 14 performance run. Each performance paid tribute to the park or other location it had been originally scheduled for. The popular tradition returned to live, in-person performances the following year.

ABOUT THE AUTHORS

Author/director Crystal Field began writing street theater in 1968 as a member of Theater of the Living Arts in Philadelphia. She wrote and performed her own outdoor theater pieces against the Vietnam War and also curated and performed many poetry programs for the Philadelphia Public Schools. There she found tremendous enthusiasm and comprehension on the part of poor and minority students for both modern and classical poetry when presented in a context of relevancy to current issues. She realized that for poetry to find its true audience, the bonds of authoritarian criticism must and can be transcended. Her earliest New York street productions were playlets written in Philadelphia and performed on the flatbed truck of Bread and Puppet Theater in Central Park. Peter Schumann, director of that troupe, was her first NY artistic supporter.

In 1971, Ms. Field became a protégé of Robert Nichols, founder of the Judson Poets Theater in Manhattan, and of Peter Schuman, founder of Bread and Puppet Theater. It is an interesting historic note that “The Expressway” by Robert Nichols, directed by Crystal Field (a Street theater satire about Robert Moses’ plan for a throughway to run across Little Italy from the West Side Highway to the FDR Drive) was actually the first production of Joseph Papp’s New York Shakespeare Festival. Nichols wrote street theater plays for TNC in its early years, but as time went on, wrote scenarios and only the first lines of songs, leaving Field to “fill in the blanks.” When Nichols announced his retirement to Vermont in 1975, he urged Field to “write your own.” The undertaking, while stressful at first, became the impetus for her to express her own topical political philosophy and to immerse her plays in that special brand of humor referred to often as “that brainy slapstick.” Her first complete work was “Mama Liberty’s Bicentennial Party” (1976), in honor of the 200th anniversary of the American Revolution.

Field has an associate’s degree in Dance from Juilliard and a BA in Philosophy from Hunter College.

Field has written and directed a completely new opera for the TNC Street Theater company each successive year. She collaborated for eleven years with composer Mark Hardwick, whose “Pump Boys and Dinettes” and “Oil City Symphony” were inspired by his street theater work with Ms. Field. At the time of his death from AIDS in 1994, he was writing a clown musical with Field called “On the Road,” which was never finished. One long-running actor in TNC street theater was Tim Robbins, who was a member of the company for six years in the 1980s, from age twelve to 18.

The Village Halloween Parade, which TNC produced single-handedly for the Parade’s first two years, grew out of the procession which preceded each Street Theater production. Ralph Lee, who created the Parade with Ms. Field, was chief designer for TNC’s Street Theater for four years before the Village Halloween Parade began.

Field has also written for TNC’s annual Halloween Ball and for an annual Yuletime pageant that was performed outdoors for 2,000 children on the Saturday before Christmas. She has written two full-length indoor plays, “Upstate” and “One Director Against His Cast.” She is co-founder and Artistic Director of TNC.

Composer Peter Dizozza was composer/musical director of TNC’s 2022 Street Theater tour, “Teacher! Teacher! or PS I Love You.” He appeared frequently in 2020-2021 in TNC’s weekly “Open ‘Tho Shut” walk-by theater productions, which demonstrated the theater’s ability to serve its neighborhood culturally during the lockdown. He is known for his simple, cheerful music with a Gershwinesque flair.  He began writing plays with music for La Mama’s Experimenta Series in 1997 and became a regular composer for productions directed by George Ferencz. Among his TNC credits are his scores for Toby Armour’s plays “Aunt Susan and Her Tennessee Waltz” (2022) and “155 Thru the Roof” (2014). His song settings include poems and texts by Shakespeare, T.S.Eliot and Thomas Hardy. He is a member of the Dramatist Guild, The Lambs Club and The New York Composers Circle.

A House Full of Flies

THEATER FOR THE NEW CITY
Executive Director, Crystal Field

Presents

A House Full of Flies

a tragic drama by WillieAnn Gissendanner.

Emotionally resonant exploration of intergenerational trauma, spirituality and the ties that both bind and break.

June 19 – July 6, 2025
Thursday, Friday, Saturday at 8:00 PM, Sunday at 3:00 PM
There will be a performance July 4th

Tickets $20, Students & Seniors $15
Run Time: 1 hour 40 minutes plus 10 minute intermission
THEATER

THEATER FOR THE NEW CITY
155 First Avenue (between 9th and 10th Street)
New York, NY 10003
Directions

Set in a small town in Georgia across two turbulent eras, 1937 and the early 1990s, “A House Full of Flies” weaves a haunting narrative of misunderstanding, delusion, deceit, and ego–fueled by religious dogma and racist mythology– that have heartbreaking consequences.

At the heart of the story is Savannah Holster, a Black American Christian woman who is a widow. She lives by her wits and presents her grown children as siblings, possibly to obscure her age. She is emotionally scarred by racist humiliations her family suffered in her childhood. From her kitchen table, she runs a faith-based healing practice, finding meaning and control in her strict religiosity. Her fraught relationship with her daughter, Deirdre, simmers with unresolved tension. She shares her home with her adult son, named Prayer, who is devoted to his controlling mother and defends their home fiercely.

When Savannah becomes involved with her lawyer, a rising white conservative politician named Jackson Vance, her world begins to unravel. Her adult daughter Deirdre, while seeking help with a legal matter of her own, inadvertently reveals to Vance that Savannah is her mother.  That realization shatters Vance’s ego, triggering a night of confrontation that ends in tragedy. In the aftermath, visions, guilt, and grief descend upon Savannah in the form of a prophetic dream that warns of doom for her young grandson. When that vision comes true it is devastating, but through it all, the bonds of kinship remain strong and hope endures. Even as shadows gather, the light of faith and fierce maternal love refuses to go out.

The play is resonant with the folklore, atmosphere and dialect of 20th century central Georgia.  The flies referred to in the title are, symbolically (and literally), evils.  Playwright Gissendanner explains, “When somebody has sent a spell, it could be manifested by flies and this is one of Savannah’s deep beliefs.” The spells symbolize the collective anxieties weighing on southern Black women of her generation.

“A House Full of Flies” is a production of Theater for the New City’s Emerging Playwrights Program. This program is integral to the theater’s mission, which includes being a center for new and innovative theater arts, discovering relevant new writing and nurturing new playwrights.

WillieAnn Gissendanner, born and raised in Gordon, Georgia, is a graduate of Paine College (Augusta, GA) and the American Academy of Dramatic Arts (NYC). Her theatrical acting resume includes Euripides’ “Medea” (Workshop Theater Company) and the solo plays “BO” by G. C. Sullivan (Workshop Theater Company, John Houseman Theater and Staten Island Armory) and “Woman” by Lawrence Holder (Paul Robeson Theatre, Brooklyn). She created, produced, and directed the NAACP ACT-SO Evening of Theater. She is author of “Pearls and Swine/This Body Is Mine,” which premiered at Theater for the New City in 2023 and was praised for its bold, unapologetic take on women’s bodily autonomy.   Her plays “Pearls and Swine/This Body is Mine” and “A Houseful of Flies” were selected for Jamaica Center for Arts and Learning’s Meet the Playwright Festival and scenes from both plays were presented there.  She is a member of SAG-AFTRA and AEA.

Gissendanner writes, “Theater For The New City is a theater community where dreams can be realized. Its arms are open to artistic souls seeking expression as playwrights, poets and actors. I am privileged and thankful to be welcomed into this community and to have my work presented on its stages. So grateful to Ms. Crystal Field and the founders of TNC for bringing into existence this vital community for performing artists.”

CAST
WillieAnn Gissendanner – Savannah
Kai Brown
Marcia Hopson
Sania Hyatt
Lola Lukas
Obinna Nwako
Aubrey Smith
Bill Tatum
Douglas Walker
Scott Williams

Classic Six

THEATER FOR THE NEW CITY
Executive Director, Crystal Field

Presents

Classic Six

May 29 – June 1, 2025
Thursday, Friday, Saturday at 8:00 PM, Sunday at 3:00 PM

Tickets $20, Students & Seniors $15
Run Time:
COMMUNITY SPACE THEATER

THEATER FOR THE NEW CITY
155 First Avenue (between 9th and 10th Street)
New York, NY 10003
Directions

CLASSIC SIX:
Join us for a showcase of 6 short plays featuring one New York apartment through the decades. Beginning in the 1950’s, we will follow a variety of New York tenants through their time in a single apartment as portrayed in these short comedies and dramas. For more information about this show, visit www.michaelluggio.com
Featuring:
Bolero by David Ives (1952)
Lunchtime by Leonard Melfi (1966)
Come Again, Another Day by Cary Pepper (1986)
Light by Jeni Mahoney* (1999)
You’re Invited! by Darren Canady (2016)
Closing Costs by Arlene Hutton (2025)
*Light is an Equity approved showcase produced by special arrangement with Playscripts Inc.

CAST
ALI CHRISTOVICH
SAMANTHA GORJANC*
SEAN CONNELLY
DYLAN CASTRO
ALLISON WELSH
EMILY MCKEON
JOHNY LUONG
JULIA ZANARDI
BRADLEY MARCO
RUSHI BIRUDALA
KIARA MELENDEZ

“Actors appearing courtesy of Actors’ Equity Association.

The Voyage Back

THEATER FOR THE NEW CITY
Executive Director, Crystal Field

Presents

A First Screening of

David Willinger and Ananim’s

New Full-Length Film

The Voyage Back

The Rough Cut

Based on the original play, Bring Them Back, which was presented at TNC in May, 2024

Monday, May 12, 2025 at 7:00 PM

SUGGESTED DONATION $10

Run Time: 2 hours
COMMUNITY SPACE

THEATER FOR THE NEW CITY
155 First Avenue (between 9th and 10th Street)
New York, NY 10003
Directions

In the meta dark comedy Bring Them Back, screenwriter Paul is still sheltering in place long after the Covid threat, only sometimes visited by his schleppy older family friend, Trudy. Now of a certain age, Paul realizes that more people he has known are dead than alive. With amusing desperation, and against Trudy’s better judgement, Paul resolves to bring them back using a medieval Cabalistic ritual that never works due to his countless mistakes. Nevertheless, random affinity groups of dead former friends, family, lovers, and enemies begin to appear. Is it all in his mind? Is it on the page? How do these unorthodox methods satisfy Paul’s desire to resolve unfinished business?

Written and Directed by David Willinger
Cinematography by Tony McNally
Design and Production Management by Dianne Ramirez
Sound Recording by Tatia Mazmanian
Film & Sound Editing by Roy Chang
Technical Supervisor Wayne Grofik
Production Assistants Dayvis Ferreras, Christopher Bello, Fran Gold
Costumes by Sarah Shah

Music by
James Yaiullo
Brama Sukarna
Basia Schechter & Pharaoh’s Daughter
Arielle Korman
And featuring: The Wavos

PERSEPHONE PALMER STEPS OUT

THEATER FOR THE NEW CITY
Executive Director, Crystal Field

Presents

PERSEPHONE PALMER STEPS OUT

A Play By CAITLYN WALTERMIRE

June 19 – July 6, 2025
Thursday, Friday, Saturday at 8:00 PM, Sunday at 3:00 PM
NO PERFORMANCE JULY 4TH

Tickets $20, Students & Seniors $15
Run Time: 2 hours, 30 minutes, plus one 10 minute intermission
CABARET THEATER

THEATER FOR THE NEW CITY
155 First Avenue (between 9th and 10th Street)
New York, NY 10003
Directions

Persephone Palmer Steps Out is set during a wintery, sub-zero Summer in the 1990s in a basement apartment hundreds of feet below the ground. This is the home of the Palmer family, headed by the tempestuous and charismatic Connie, whose marriage to the devoted and enabling Herm oversees a fraught dynamic with her fractious stepson Joe. The occasional wandering-ins of Stef, Joe’s girlfriend, and their new friend Paul punctuate the isolated family’s routine, as do the shambolic visits from Connie’s brother Richard and his much-younger wife Lisa. Despite the magical setting of the play, the dynamics between the characters are rooted in realism – except for the fact that Persie, the Palmer’s 13-year-old human daughter, is the family’s “cat.” Yet as the landscape shifts and Persie begins to bond with some of the new visitors, it appears that some changes may be underway – for better or for worse. With character archetypes derived from Greek mythology, Persephone Palmer Steps Out is a darkly hilarious exploration of the god-like nature of familial hierarchies, the contingencies of love, conditional acceptance, and the divine, desperate pursuit of control. Trigger warnings: Domestic violence, references to sexual assault.

“This play explores parents’ godlike power from their children’s perspective—divine abuse of power, fate v. free will, sexual influence, and a hero’s journey—and so, its characters’ relationships reflect those between figures in Greek mythology,” shared playwright Caitlyn Waltermire. “Hades is a woman now! References to perpetual winter, ferry rides, snake sex, goose foreplay, smell of sulfur, etc. are all in this vein. Being a thirteen-year-old girl has been a heady nightmare since ancient Greece.”

 

Playwright – Caitlyn Waltermire

CAST
Persephone Palmer – SOPHIE KELLY-HEDRICK*
Connie Palmer – ZUHAIRAH*
Herm Palmer – GUY VENTOLIERE*
Joe Palmer – ALEC FEBBRARO
Paul – DIOGO DE OLIVEIRA
Stef – JESSALYN CHARLES
Richard Scott – PHIL OETIKER
Lisa Scott – ELIZABETH SHERMAN

*these Actors are appearing courtesy of Actors Equity Association

PRODUCTION
Director – Natalie Thomas
Assistant Director/Intimacy Coordinator – Alysia Homminga
Playwright – Caitlyn Waltermire
Sound Designer – Wendy Maciver
Lighting Designer – Lauren Lee
Scenic Designer – Maren Prophit

Staged Reading: The Generator Sessions

THEATER FOR THE NEW CITY
Executive Director, Crystal Field

Presents

Staged Reading: The Generator Sessions

Four new plays by:
Eduardo Machado – Dev Meenagh – Kimberly Pau – Michael Sharp

May 1 – May 11, 2025
Thursday, Friday, Saturday at 8:00 PM, Sunday at 3:00 PM
Two weekends only

Tickets $20 tickets, $15 Students and Seniors
Run Time:
COMMUNITY SPACE

THEATER FOR THE NEW CITY
155 First Avenue (between 9th and 10th Street)
New York, NY 10003
Directions

Four Evangelists Walk into a Fog

THEATER FOR THE NEW CITY
Executive Director, Crystal Field

Presents

Four Evangelists Walk into a Fog

by Douglas Lackey
Founding of a major new world religion is an occasion for intellectual dark comedy.

May 1 – May 18, 2025
Thursday, Friday, Saturday at 8:00 PM, Sunday at 3:00 PM

Tickets $20 tickets, $15 Students and Seniors
Run Time: 1 hour 15 minutes plus intermission
JOHNSON THEATER

THEATER FOR THE NEW CITY
155 First Avenue (between 9th and 10th Street)
New York, NY 10003
Directions

Matthew, Mark, Luke and John wrote four differing gospels and created Christianity. These four evangelists actually never met, but they do–as members of a comedic literary synod –in “Four Evangelists Walk into a Fog” by Douglas Lackey. The results are hilarious and profound. Theater for the New City (TNC), which has been Lackey’s theatrical home since 2003, will present the work’s premiere run May 1 to 18, directed by Mark Harborth.

Playwright Douglas Lackey has two lives, as a playwright and a philosophy professional. He holds a Ph.D. in Philosophy from Yale and is a Professor of Philosophy at Baruch College, CUNY, where he has taught since 1972. As a playwright, he specializes in serious portraits of historical/intellectual figures in moral dilemmas, including Ludwig Wittgenstein, Giulio Caesare Vanini (a free-thinking physician-philosopher of 17th century Italy), Bertrand Russell, Martin Heidegger, Hannah Arendt, and General Heywood Hansell (who advocated for a strategy of daylight precision bombing over saturation bombing in WWII). All of Lackey’s previous plays at TNC have been praised for their deft mixtures of philosophy, romance and politics. He has also written several other historical plays that he calls “comedies of ideas.” This is one of them.

It was inevitable, perhaps, that Mr. Lackey would take up the subject of contradictions among the Gospels, which is quite popular in theological, academic, and secular circles. It has been widely discussed for centuries and remains an active topic in biblical studies, apologetics, and skeptical critiques of Christianity. The four Gospels differ on key details, which include Jesus’ genealogy, his final words on the cross and the timing of the resurrection appearances. Mark and John omit the virgin birth. Paul’s letters, written earlier than these four accounts, rarely mention Jesus’ earthly life and contradict Gospel accounts on the resurrection’s witnesses and Jesus’ teachings on the Law.

These various disagreements provide food for fun and amicable debate in the play, with the contradictions providing natural comedic tension. It could be mistaken for a debate between philosophy professors in the faculty lounge of an American college. The foursome are aware that their writings will become the foundation of a major world religion, so their tone is collegial and good-natured. If there is any intellectual critique, it is based on logic. Comedic anachronisms heighten the satire as the evangelists struggle with the weight of shaping a new faith, bickering over details while Mary Magdalene, their “reality check,” cuts through their abstractions with raw lived experience. It’s done with rapid-fire dialogue, shifting alliances and moments of deep introspection. Think “No Exit” meets “The West Wing” with a theological twist.

Lackey even manages to inject some backstage humor, as in this argument:

John: The psalms say the Messiah’s bones shall not be broken. No broken legs. Let’s move on to the Resurrection.

Matthew: We have problems with the resurrection. Lots of skepticism. Many Jews say the body was stolen from the tomb. Some even say that the followers of Jesus hired an actor to go around Judea pretending to be Jesus. The actor put holes in his hands to make it real.

Mark: Who would believe that? No actor will put holes through his hands just to get paid.

Luke: Apparently you don’t know many actors.

Douglas Lackey has a 22 year relationship with Theater for the New City, which has presented all his plays to-date. His first play, “Kaddish in East Jerusalem” (2003), dealt with issues of the Second Intifada. His “Daylight Precision” (2014) was a historical drama examining “just war” theories through an unsung hero of World War II, Gen. Haywood Hansell. Lackey’s “Arendt-Heidegger: A Love Story” (2018) dramatized the unlikely romance between Martin Heidegger and Hannah Arendt. His “Ludwig and Bertie” (2019) charted the forty-year love/hate relationship between Bertrand Russell and his most famous student, Ludwig Wittgenstein. His “The Wayward Daughter of Judah the Prince” (2021) was a sort of a philosopher’s “Thelma and Louise” in which the daughter of Judah the Prince (compiler of The Mishnah–the core section of The Talmud) runs off with her Christian slave girl lover to measure herself against the conflicting philosophies of the period. His “Spies for the Pope” (2023) charted the tragic career of Giulio Caesare Vanini (1585-1619), an Italian philosopher recruited by the Vatican (in Lackey’s telling) for an impossible mission: averting the Thirty Years War by reconciling the Catholic and Protestant antagonisms in key European countries. All these plays have been critically praised as explosive dramas of ideas, romance and politics.

Lackey writes, “I am grateful to Crystal Field and Theater for the New City for encouraging me to present this story. TNC is willing to take on my ‘comedies of ideas’ and these are quite different from the contemporary obsession with plays of jumbled identities and failed relationships. Kudos to a theater that will buck the mainstream.”

Director Mark Harborth was Producing Artistic Director of Gallery Players in Brooklyn, where he has staged “Ragtime,” “Dreamgirls,” “Gypsy,” “Evita,” “Rent,” “It Shoulda Been You,” “A Few Good Men,” “One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest,” “Chess” and “Run For Your Wife,” among others. His regional credits include “Hello Dolly,” “Jesus Christ Superstar,” “High Spirits,” “Chicago,” “Children of a Lesser God,” “Sweeney Todd” and “Pirates of Penzance.” He is a member of the Stage Directors and Choreographers Society.

CAST
Zephyr Caulfield (Matthew)
John Gionis (Mark)
Nick Freedson (Luke)
Matthew Foley (John)
Andy English (Paul)
Barbara McCulloh (Mary Magdalene)

PRODUCTION
Set design is by Jerry Mittelhauser
Lighting design is by Scott Cally
Costume design is by Joey Haws
Stage manager is Cassidy Byron

TNC’s New City, New Blood Reading Series: The Big Finish

Theater for the New City

Executive Director, Crystal Field

Presents

TNC’s New City, New Blood Reading Series:

The Big Finish

Monday, May 12, 2025 at 7:00 PM

FREE

$5 Suggested Donation

THEATER FOR THE NEW CITY
155 First Avenue (between 9th & 10th Street)
New York, NY 10003
Directions

Pamela has a husband, a daughter and a terminal cancer diagnosis. Choosing to forego treatments that would only delay the inevitable, she breaks the news to her family: she’s moving out and breaking off all contact to explore what could have been with widower Gus Giannopolis, an unpursued connection from her past. The Big Finish is both humorous and philosophical, examining how much we owe to the people we love and if the process of death is about our own desires or the comfort of the ones we leave behind.

CAST
Richie Byrne
Hunter Corbett
Ana Goldseker
Michael Patrick Sullivan
Chelsea Lee Walker

Vinnie Nardiello – Writer
Vinnie has been writing for theater and television for two decades and with his most recent staged play Rubber enjoying a run at Theater for the New City in 2024. His debut play, The Boom, was featured at the Dream-Up Festival at Theater for the New City and his 2022 play Diving Horses was seen at the NuBox Theater under the production of Theater 68. Another script, Li’l, was featured as part of the reading series at Black Box PAC in Englewood, NJ. He has also created Duppet, a short film found on Amazon Prime, and produced a pilot, Radio Gods, starring Paul Provenza and Rick Overton. His work can be heard on The Late Show with Stephen Colbert, SNL’s Weekend Update, ESPN, and Sirius XM Radio. In addition to his own offerings on the stand-up comedy circuit, Vinnie has had his work performed at the White House Correspondents’ Dinner. He is thrilled to be back at Theater for the New City.

Jake Hart – Director
Selected New York credits include The Democracy Project at Federal Hall, Jesus Hopped the A Train at The Atlantic, Salvage at The Public, and Bury The Dead at Transport Group. In selected television Jake has appeared in The Deuce, Shades of Blue, The Blacklist, Sneaky Pete and others. As a voice actor you have heard him everywhere. His campaigns have won multiple awards, and he is honored to be the current representative of Smokey Bear. Catch his short film, Big George, on the festival circuit this year.